Went to see “High Fidelity” last night. Generally, I don’t like musicals much with the exception of some revivals (namely those by Cole Porter, Irving Berlin and Kander & Ebb), where the music was actually great music, much of which plays well far removed from the context of the stage. Although my expectations going into the show were extremely low, I wanted to see it anyway to satisfy my curiosity. ( I also had highly discounted tickets; I would have never paid full price for this.) I love the movie “High Fidelity” (seen it three or four times) and dug the novel even more. Great movie soundtrack too. So I just had to see how they adapted this for the stage.
I absolutely hated the first half. I didn’t hate the second half, but didn’t exactly like it either. For a musical about music, the music wasn’t so great with the exception of a few songs such as the rap fantasy number and the closing soul number called “Turn the World Off (And Turn You On),” which I thought was a cover of Marvin Gaye or Barry White or someone of that ilk, but apparently was an original. My favorite aspect of the show was probably the sets, though they were a bit distracting as I kept wondering which album covers-if they were in fact real album covers-were in the store. The drama never developed and anything I felt for the characters was based on feelings derived from other versions of this story. If I didn’t know the story so well, I would have really hated this production; the fact that I had all that background made the experience richer for me. Without it, the show would have really seemed shallow. The guy who played Barry, the Jack Black role in the movie, did a pretty good Jack Black, but not as good as Jack Black does Jack Black.
Some changes were made to bring the show up to date and appeal to the Broadway audience. First of all, the setting was changed to Brooklyn from Chicago in the movie, which was moved from the novel’s setting of London. One of the memorable jokes from the book and movie revolved around a father wanting to buy Stevie Wonder’s “I Just Called to Say I Love You” for his daughter and Barry ripping him to shreds for his bad taste. In the Broadway version, it was altered to be a Celine Dion record.
To me, “High Fidelity” represents one of the worst trends on Broadway, the Hollywoodization of theater. Whereas Hollywood remakes every movie from 20 or more years ago, Broadway is turning every Hollywood comedy of recent years into a musical. In addition to this one, recent examples are “Dirty Rotten Scoundrel” and “The Wedding Singer.” I saw the former and found it atrocious. They take a popular movie-although I don’t think Hi Fi was such a hit-and pen some lyrics in the course of a weekend and throw it out there with some slick marketing. “High Fidelity” would have made a much better play (even with just a recording of the movie soundtrack), but its all about the bottom line and I suppose tourists and people from New Jersey much prefer musicals.
I was left wondering once again if Nick Hornby, one of my favorite writers, is an utter sellout. He seems more than willing to take a nice hunk of cash in exchange for allowing his books to be changed and ruined any which way. As mentioned, the setting of “High Fidelity” was changed twice; “Fever Pitch,” a memoir of Hornby’s obsession with the British football club Arsenal became a Jimmy Fallon-Drew Barrymore vehicle about the Boston Red Sox. Another book, “How to Be Good” will be made into a movie and no doubt it will be moved from the U.K. to America as well.
At intermission, two women from Jersey who sat in the row in front of us, were decrying the possible death of the new musical and dissing snobbish critics who lean toward revivals. One of them said that if you cleaned up the language, “High Fidelity” could make a good high school production. One half of a gay couple in front of us seemed to enjoying the hell out of the show during the first act; he was really yukking it up at parts that I didn’t find funny at all. Then, oddly, they never came back after the intermission. Either one of them was a doctor paged for a medical emergency or their laughter was completely sarcastic and they hated the show.
On the way home, an elderly woman (of Eastern European origin, I think) sitting next to Aya noticed her reading her “Playbill” and started a conversation. She’d just seen “Chorus Line” and detested it. She did, however, enthusiastically recommend seeing the Alvin Ailey dance performance. According to the lady, it was better than anything in the city now. In fact, she’d seen it six times already this year. I’ve never really been interesting in seeing a dance-only performance, but she got me thinking that maybe we should check it out before their season ends in a few weeks.